Updated: Best ReConvert Alternatives for Shopify Plus Merchants in 2025
ReConvert has been a go-to app for post-purchase upselling on Shopify, especially for stores just starting to optimize their order confirmation and thank-you page flows. But for high-growth Shopify Plus merchants, limitations in customization, scalability, and native checkout integrations can hinder performance. In this updated guide, we explore the best ReConvert alternatives — apps with deeper extensibility, enterprise-grade control, and proven ROI across Shopify Plus brands.
Why Shopify Plus Brands Are Moving Beyond ReConvert
While ReConvert remains a strong entry-level tool, high-growth brands are outgrowing it due to:
- Limited Checkout Extensibility Integration – ReConvert operates primarily on thank-you pages, not the native Shopify checkout.
- Inadequate A/B Testing – Few tools to compare pre- and post-purchase funnel performance.
- Scaling Constraints – Flat features for complex checkout flows and international markets.
- Revenue-Sharing Model – As GMV grows, ReConvert’s commission-based pricing becomes a drag on margins.
These limitations have pushed Shopify Plus merchants toward tools purpose-built for native checkout customization, enterprise reporting, and international scaling.
ReConvert Alternatives Comparison Table (2025)
Side-by-Side: Original vs Updated Comparison Table
Tool Deep Dives & Shopify Plus Use Cases
UpsellPlus
- Features: Checkout-based upsells using Checkout Extensibility
- Pricing: Starts at $49/month
- Use Case: The Beard Club used UpsellPlus to insert one-click offers in Shopify Plus checkout, increasing AOV by 21%
AfterSell
- Features: Thank-you page customization, post-purchase funnels
- Pricing: $34.99–$99.99/month based on order volume. Free dev store plan available.
- Use Case: Moonbrew used AfterSell to introduce reorder offers on thank-you pages
Honeycomb Upsell & Cross Sell
- Features: Drag-and-drop funnel builder, pre/post-purchase upsells
- Pricing: From $49.99/month
- Use Case: Hygge Haven launched seasonal bundles using Honeycomb's funnel templates
SellUp
- Features: Product page upsells, trigger-based display logic
- Pricing: $14.99/month
- Use Case: Used by lean teams for quick upsell setup without custom development
Candy Rack
- Features: One-click upsells, multilingual popup support
- Pricing: $49.99/month
- Use Case: DFTBA deployed localized offers using Candy Rack for EU markets
Zipify OneClickUpsell (OCU)
- Features: Post-purchase upsells, A/B testing, one-click landing pages (Shopify App Store)
- Pricing: From $35/month + commission
- Use Case: Brands used Zipify to test pre- and post-purchase flows for improved conversion
CartHook
- Features (Vendor Website Verified): Post-purchase upsells integrated in Shopify admin, drag-and-drop funnel builder, one-click offers, A/B testing, analytics
- Pricing: Free for up to 100 monthly store orders; paid plans start at $10/month, with a 1% revenue share on generated sales (verified May 2025)
- Use Case: Popular with tech brands and accessory stores seeking simple funnel creation and post-purchase optimization
Strategic Considerations for Plus Merchants
1. Checkout Extensibility Readiness
Shopify is deprecating checkout.liquid for Plus stores by August 2025. Apps like UpsellPlus and Checkout Blocks support Checkout UI Extensions, allowing native upsells inside the new multi-page checkout.
2. A/B Testing and Funnel Analytics
Scaling requires fast iteration on funnel performance. UpsellPlus and Zipify offer native A/B testing. Others rely on Google Analytics or third-party integrations.
3. Internationalization & Localization
Candy Rack leads in multilingual support. UpsellPlus supports Shopify Markets for currency-based targeting. This is key for brands operating globally. Global operations at minimum require the ability for users to transact in local currency.
4. Site Speed & Load Performance
Client-side upsell apps can add latency. JS-heavy apps can impact user conversions. UpsellPlus and Checkout Blocks use Shopify-hosted Checkout Extensions which don’t block page render or checkout speed.
5. Security & Compliance
Checkout-based apps must meet PCI-DSS standards. UpsellPlus and Zipify are Shopify-vetted. CartHook operates outside Shopify's native checkout (Stripe-based).
6. White-Glove Support
UpsellPlus and AfterSell offer onboarding teams, priority support, and solution architect access—a critical factor for enterprise merchants. Waiting around to deploy features that are critical to your bottom line.
Checklist for Migrating from ReConvert to an Alternative
You’ve done all your due diligence and decided that a move to a new app is going to help elevate your brand to the next level. We of course hope it’s to UpSell Plus, however, regardless of which app you select, you’ll need to ensure you’re ready. That’s why we created this checklist.
Technical Readiness
- Are you planning to use Shopify Checkout Extensibility?
- Have you confirmed whether the new app supports multi-page checkout integration?
- Is the app compliant with Shopify’s checkout.liquid deprecation timeline (August 2025)?
- Does your new upsell tool support Shopify’s Checkout UI Extensions?
- Do you need support for Shopify Functions (e.g., conditional logic, discounts)?
Optimization & Testing
- Does the new app offer native A/B testing?
- Can you preview or simulate upsell flows before publishing?
- Is analytics granular enough to show AOV uplift, conversion % by step, and funnel performance?
- Are reporting dashboards compatible with GA4 or third-party BI tools?
- Can you export upsell performance data?
Internationalization & Audience Targeting
- Does the app support Shopify Markets (localized pricing and currency)?
- Does it offer multilingual upsell experiences?
- Can you target upsells by geography or market segment?
- Does the tool auto-detect browser language or country?
Workflow & Customization
- Can offers be managed without developer involvement?
- Does the app support drag-and-drop or visual builder functionality?
- Can upsells be personalized based on cart contents or customer tags?
- Does the app allow for multi-step or dynamic upsell paths?
Performance & Infrastructure
- Will the upsell experience add load time to checkout or thank-you page?
- Are any scripts blocking or delaying checkout rendering?
- Is the app hosted via Shopify (serverless) or external scripts?
Pricing & Contracts
- Is the pricing model flat-rate or based on revenue share?
- Are there any hidden costs (e.g., per-order fees or feature gates)?
- Does the app offer a free trial or dev store sandbox for migration testing?
Onboarding & Support
- Does the provider offer migration help, onboarding, or priority support?
- Is white-glove service included or available for Plus merchants?
Download ReConvert Migration Checklist
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: Which ReConvert alternative works best with Shopify Plus checkout customization?
A: UpsellPlus — Fully supports Checkout Extensibility API for native checkout upsells.
Q: Do any of these tools offer A/B testing?
A: UpsellPlus and Zipify OCU — Both offer built-in split testing tools for pre- and post-purchase offers.
Q: What’s the easiest alternative for new or leaner teams?
A: SellUp — Lightweight, simple to deploy, and offers smart trigger logic with minimal setup.
Q: Can I serve different upsells to international markets?
A: Candy Rack — Verified support for multilingual popups and currency-based targeting via Shopify Markets.
Q: What tools support Stripe checkout compatibility?
A: CartHook — Works with Stripe-based post-checkout offers outside the native Shopify checkout.
Q: Can I upsell directly in the checkout, not just after the order?
A: UpsellPlus — Uses Checkout UI Extensions to insert upsells directly in the Shopify Plus checkout flow.
Q: Are any of these apps compatible with Shopify’s new checkout architecture?
A: UpsellPlus and Checkout Blocks — Both use Shopify's Checkout Extensibility framework, which replaces checkout.liquid for Plus stores.
Q: What’s the best option for enterprise-level onboarding and support?
A: UpsellPlus and AfterSell — Offer dedicated account managers, onboarding teams, and priority response channels.
