Best PickyStory alternatives for Shopify in 2026

Last updated: October 15, 2026. Pricing and ratings are taken from each app's Shopify App Store listing on that date.

Quick answer: PickyStory is now called Amplify | Bundles & Upsell, from $99.50/month. The best alternative depends on what you used it for: UpsellPlus covers upsells, add-ons and free gifts across the whole funnel on flat tiers, Bundler is a strong free bundle app, and Frequently Bought Together focuses on FBT widgets.

Disclosure: UpsellPlus is our app. Competitor facts are taken from each app's Shopify App Store listing, and we say where each one is the better fit.

Why Shopify stores look for a PickyStory alternative

PickyStory (4.5 from 538 reviews) has been renamed Amplify | Bundles & Upsell. It covers product bundles, frequently bought together, BOGO, quantity breaks and upsell offers. The most common reasons stores look elsewhere:

• PickyStory is now Amplify. The app was renamed Amplify | Bundles & Upsell, with a single plan starting at $99.50 a month.
• Price scales with store revenue. The volume-based plan grows with your total store revenue, not with what bundles earn.
• Simpler needs. Stores that only want an FBT widget or basic bundles can pay far less elsewhere.

If you already run PickyStory bundles and the price works, Amplify keeps the same bundling engine and support team.

PickyStory alternatives compared

The 5 best PickyStory alternatives

1. UpsellPlus

Choose it over PickyStory if: You want upsells and free gifts across product page, cart, checkout and post-purchase, with add-ons and bundles, on flat tiers priced on upsell revenue rather than store revenue.

Rating: 5.0 (146) on the Shopify App Store.

• Offers chosen by hand, from collections or tags, or automatically by ShopBrain (similar, complementary, subscription upgrade, size upgrade, complete the set, clearance and more)
• Upsells to subscriptions with Shopify Subscriptions, Recharge, Appstle, Seal, Skio, Stay AI and other selling-plan apps
• 25 targeting rules, including Klaviyo segments, Shopify Markets, B2B and cart contents
• Multivariate A/B tests and holdout experiments that measure incremental revenue (on the $119 plans and up)
• Checkout customizations on Shopify Plus: styling, trust content, payment and delivery method visibility

Pricing: You can build and preview offers for free; going live needs a paid plan. Launch is $49/month (up to $500 in upsell revenue), Shopify Plus $119/month (up to $2,000, adds checkout upsells and A/B testing) and Scale $199/month (up to $5,000). No commission on sales; 14-day free trial on paid plans.

Watch out for: Checkout placements need Shopify Plus, as with every app that offers checkout upsells (a Shopify restriction).

2. Bundler

Choose it over PickyStory if: You mainly want bundles, quantity breaks and mix & match, on a free or low-cost plan.

Rating: 4.9 (2,734) on the Shopify App Store.

• Unlimited bundles and orders on the free plan
• Mix & match and custom landing pages on Premium
• Bundle analytics on Executive
• Shopify POS support

Pricing: Free plan with unlimited bundles. Premium $9.99/month adds mix & match and funnel upsells; Executive $19.99/month adds analytics. 7-day free trial.

Watch out for: Bundles and quantity breaks only; checkout, post-purchase and cart drawer offers aren't listed.

3. Selleasy

Choose it over PickyStory if: You want FBT bundles plus cart and post-purchase offers at a flat price.

Rating: 4.9 (2,747) on the Shopify App Store.

• Frequently bought together bundles and product add-ons
• Cart pop-up funnels and in-cart upsells
• Post-purchase and thank-you page offers
• AI recommendations on higher plans

Pricing: Free under 50 orders/month, then $15, $49 or $99/month. Checkout upsells for Shopify Plus are on the Pro plan and up.

Watch out for: AI recommendations are capped per month by plan.

4. Frequently Bought Together (CBB)

Choose it over PickyStory if: You want a dedicated Amazon-style FBT widget with AI recommendations.

Rating: 4.9 (1,210) on the Shopify App Store.

Pricing: Free Starter (3 manual bundles). Professional $9.99 (up to 50 orders), $24.99 (up to 500) and $39.99/month (500+). 14-day free trial.

Watch out for: Plans step up with total orders; the widget shows on product and cart pages, not checkout or post-purchase.

5. Qikify Upsell & Cross-sell

Choose it over PickyStory if: You want BOGO, free gifts and FBT offers at a flat price by Shopify plan.

Rating: 4.8 (677) on the Shopify App Store.

Pricing: Free plan with one live campaign. Basic $9.99, Grow $24.99 and Advanced $49.99/month depending on your Shopify plan. 7-day free trial.

Watch out for: The free plan allows one live campaign; checkout upsells need Shopify Plus.

How to switch from PickyStory

1. List your live PickyStory offers and how much revenue each brings in.
2. Rebuild the top earners first in the new app, on the same placements.
3. Turn off PickyStory's offers when the new ones go live, so shoppers don't see duplicates.
4. Compare upsell revenue and AOV against your old baseline; a holdout test shows what the new offers actually add.

Frequently asked questions

Is PickyStory still on Shopify?

Yes, under a new name: Amplify | Bundles & Upsell. Same developer and bundling engine, now from $99.50 a month with volume-based pricing.

What is the best PickyStory alternative?

For upsells, add-ons and free gifts across product page, cart, checkout and post-purchase, UpsellPlus. For bundles only, Bundler has a free plan; for a dedicated FBT widget, Frequently Bought Together.

How much does PickyStory (Amplify) cost?

Amplify has one 'Pay as You Grow' plan from $99.50 a month, volume-based on store revenue, with a 30-day free trial.

Which PickyStory alternative has a free plan?

Bundler, Frequently Bought Together, Selleasy and Qikify Upsell all have free plans for live offers. UpsellPlus is free to build, with a 14-day trial on paid plans.

Try UpsellPlus

Build your offers in UpsellPlus for free, then go live with a 14-day free trial on any paid plan. Start for free or book a demo.

Related: the best frequently bought together apps, the 10 best upsell apps for Shopify.